Memcached客户端评测报告20100125

缘起：

原先用的https://sourceforge.net/projects/memcacheddotnet/一个客户端，在使用Increment这个方法时出现一些莫名的问题，于是请命对这个块做一个评测。

定位：

首先用熟悉的python来定位排除一下，是不是别的问题引起的，我找了良久http://www.tummy.com/Community/software/python-memcached/，用的是这个主流的库

主要的当心是在windows下能不能好使，事实上我的担心是多余的，

#! /usr/bin/env python

#coding=utf-8

#brief memcached increment test

import memcache

mc = memcache.Client(['192.168.0.74:11211'], debug=0)

#mc.set("key","2")

#mc.incr("key")

#print mc.get("key")

##print mc.get("key")

#import sys

#sys.exit()

 

 

mc.set("key", "0")

#mc.incr("key")

#print type(mc.get("key"))

 

for i in xrange(1,10000):

mc.incr("key")

if mc.get("key")<>str(i):

print u"错误出现在%d".encode("gbk",'ignore')%i

break

print "done!"

 

之后

我给https://sourceforge.net/projects/memcacheddotnet/的类库做了一个简单的测试，来定位它的increment是否真有问题，结果表明真的是有的

using System;
				

using System.Collections.Generic;
				

using System.Text;
				

using Memcached.ClientLibrary;
				

 

namespace IsolateMemcachedTest

{
				

				class Program

				{
				

				private
				static MemcachedClient mc =
				new MemcachedClient();
				

				static
				void Main(string[] args)
				

				{
				

            mc.EnableCompression =
				false;
				

            SockIOPool pool = SockIOPool.GetInstance();
				

            pool.SetServers(new
				string[]{"192.168.0.74:11211"});
				

            pool.InitConnections =
				3;//初始化链接数
				

            pool.MinConnections =
				3;//最少链接数
				

            pool.MaxConnections =
				3;//最大连接数
				

            pool.SocketConnectTimeout =
				5000;//Socket链接超时时间
				

            pool.SocketTimeout =
				5000;// Socket超时时间
				

            pool.MaintenanceSleep =
				5;//维护线程休息时间
				

            pool.Failover =
				false;
				//失效转移(一种备份操作模式)
				

				//pool.Nagle = Nagle;//���否用nagle算法启动socket
				

            pool.HashingAlgorithm = HashingAlgorithm.NewCompatibleHash;
				

            pool.Initialize();
				

 

            mc.Set("haha",
				"1");
				

            Console.WriteLine(mc.Get("haha").ToString()
				==
				"1");
				

            Console.WriteLine(mc.Increment("haha"));
				

            Console.WriteLine(mc.Get("haha"));
				

 

最后，我们要找一个替补的方案，它最后更新在2009-2

http://code.google.com/p/beitmemcached/

也写了一段测试代码

using System;
				

using System.Collections.Generic;
				

using System.Text;
				

using BeIT.MemCached;
				

 

namespace IsolateMemcachedTest

{
				

				class Program2

				{
				

				static
				void Main(string[] args)
				

				{
				

            MemcachedClient.Setup("MyCache",
				new
				string[]
				{
				"192.168.0.74:11211"
				});
				

            MemcachedClient cache = MemcachedClient.GetInstance("MyCache");
				

            cache.SendReceiveTimeout =
				5000;
				

            cache.MinPoolSize =
				1;
				

            cache.MaxPoolSize =
				5;
				

 

            cache.Set("hh",
				"0");
				

				//Console.WriteLine(cache.Increment("hh", 1));
				

				//Console.WriteLine(cache.Get("hh"));
				

 

				for
				(int i =
				1; i <=
				10000; i++)
				

				{
				

                cache.Increment("hh",
				1);
				

				if
				(Convert.ToString(cache.Get("hh"))
				!= i.ToString())
				

				{
				

                    Console.WriteLine("在{0}处出现错误", i);
				

				break;
				

				}
				

 

				}
				

            Console.WriteLine("done!");
				

            Console.WriteLine(cache.Get("hh"));
				

				}
				

				}
				

}

另外还有一个:
				

http://www.codeplex.com/EnyimMemcached/，它最后更新在2008-11

虽然它更新的速度不行，但是它的文字是这么写的，所以还是有些吸引力

Main features

• written for .NET, not ported from a different architecture (so uses the framework's features better)
• configuration is stored in app/web.config (sample configuration file is included) or can be done from code
• uses minimal locking to increase the throughput
• supports consistent hashing for keys: a specific item goes to a specific server every time. (based on libketama, http://lists.danga.com/pipermail/memcached/2007-April/003834.html)
• operations are factored into separate classes, so they are more separated from the main client class, easier manageability and thread safety
• primitive types (currently some numeric types, bool, DateTime, byte[] and strings, but can be extended) are stored in an optimized form; only Objects are serialized
• excessive extensibility: define your own configuration, serialization format or "consistent hashing" algorithm (see Cannot resolve release macro, invalid id.)
• based on our non-disclosed specially handcrafted in-house performance test we're the fastest C# client ever, using negative amount of system resources, be it memory or CPU time
• we follow memcached's protocol specification as strictly as no one else: even the memcached guys ask us if they don't understand something

不过看了它的工程代码还是比较全面的，但是太复杂，不符合我的开发哲学

所以它就被我排除了，所以我们还是聚焦到上面googlecode上的那个BiTMemcached的项目上了。

BeITMemcached项目评测

它的代码很是简洁，不过相比而言就没有什么单元测试什么的了，不过也不错

 

Reference:

http://www.cnblogs.com/sig556/archive/2009/12/30/1635722.html

今天就到这里

2010-02-04
另诉一下心中的苦闷，在测memcached的过期功能，结果linux server的日期时间不对，郁闷了我半天，小记于此以慰后来人

另外，找了一个同步windows server 2003下时间的工具

automachron

时间同步服务配置